Today a friend has been sentenced to 3 years in prison. She has 2 teenage daughters who will be adults by the time she is released.
There's no question that what she did was wrong (sex with a 15 year old student). She will never teach again and will be on the sex offenders register indefinately.
I feel sad because she has lost 3 years of her life, 3 years of her daughter's lives and 3 years of her nephews' lives who have recently lost their mum (who, incidently, was suffering from terminal cancer at the time of the affair).
I feel sad because she was a bubbly, intelligent, thoughtful and excellent teacher and woman and I wonder what 3 years in prison will do to that. She was grieving the loss of her close sister and working through the end of her marriage. She chose the wrong person to lean on and find comfort in. It doesn't justify the relationship and it was an abuse of a powerful position. I don't believe she is a predator or a paedofile however. As the judge said to her,
"This is a very sad story for all concerned, not least yourself. It is clear your life had come to a very low ebb. You started to abuse your position of trust. Eventually you lured him into intercourse which should never have happened."
Councelling or therapy would have been a good way to go but i can't see how separation from her children and loss of freedom is going to help her or the boy. What is the purpose of the punishment? She is already all too aware of the wrongness of her actions, admitted them and is ashamed of them. She admitted to the fault being hers "at the earliest opportunity".
I wonder how differently i would feel if it were a male friend and a 15 year old girl. Or if it were one of her daughters, or mine, and a male teacher. To be honest it makes me a little queazy thinking about it...
Today i have lost a friend on facebook. Her profile no longer exists. She is someone i have admired as a brilliant mum and as a teacher who made a terrible mistake for which she will suffer way beyond the 3 year prison sentence.
Whether the sentence was right or wrong, harsh or not, today i feel sad.